ApartmentBuildings.NYC

Areas

ManhattanBrowse buildingsBrooklynBrowse buildingsQueensBrowse buildingsBronxBrowse buildingsStaten IslandBrowse buildingsJersey CityBrowse buildingsHobokenBrowse buildings
Building exterior 6 photos

Sutton Marquis

417 East 57th Street, NY 100224.2 ★ (61 reviews)
Rental building
Website

Summary

Sutton Marquis is a 124-apartment Sutton Place rental with large windows, a 24-hour concierge, fitness center, resident lounge, landscaped courtyard and package receiving. Residents praise the staff, cleanliness, space and higher-floor views; unusually high metered electricity charges and winter comfort are the dominant concerns.

124 unitsOpened 1974Managed by Marquis Apartments

Reviews

Residents are consistently positive about the concierge, porters and maintenance team, even in otherwise critical reviews. The central tradeoff is cost: several residents say the newer metered utility charges changed how the building's value felt to them.

Google
4.2
61 reviews
Openigloo
4.6
9 reviews
Yelp
2.6
12 reviews

What residents praise

The building staff earn sustained praise

Residents describe friendly concierges, responsive maintenance and a clean, professionally run building.

Apartments feel spacious and bright

Large rooms, broad windows and higher-floor views are recurring positives, with relatively little neighbor noise in the available feedback.

The location is convenient and residential

Residents value the East Side setting and access to everyday shopping while remaining slightly removed from the busiest Midtown blocks.

What residents complain about

Metered electricity can be expensive

Several residents report monthly bills above $300 despite modest use, making the apartment's metering and recent bill history important to review.

Winter comfort varies by apartment

Some residents describe cold or drafty rooms even while paying high utility charges, especially around older windows.

A few shared facilities feel modest

Individual reviews mention a small gym and temporary laundry-machine outages, although the latter was reportedly repaired quickly.

Amenities

A 24-hour attended lobby with concierge, a 24/7 Peloton-equipped fitness center and a landscaped courtyard anchor this Sutton Place rental tower. Apartments come with dishwashers and air conditioning, and laundry is handled in a central shared laundry room.

In the apartment
Air conditioning
Dishwasher
In the building
24-hour doorman
Elevator
Fitness center
Pool
Not available
Shared outdoor space
On-site parking
Not available
Package service
Resident storage
Not available
Shared laundry

Also here: Bike storage · Resident lounge · Community room and business center · Key-fob controlled access · On-site management and maintenance · Pet-friendly

Location

Sutton Marquis is located at 417 East 57th Street, New York, NY 10022. Sutton Marquis is on East 57th Street in Sutton Place, near the East River, neighborhood shops and Midtown offices. The subway is a longer walk than at central Midtown buildings, so test the route you would use most often.

TransitSupermarketsParks
  • 9 min
    59 St456NRW
  • 9 min
    Lexington Av/59 St456NRW
  • 10 min
    Lexington Av/53 St6EF
  • 12 min
    Lexington Av/63 StMQ
  • 14 min
    51 St6EF

Building records

Housing complaints are relatively uncommon compared with similar buildings, with noise and roaches the largest categories. Nearby exterior work may bring disruption around the building.

Reported housing complaintsPast 3 years

Reported housing complaints
Housing-related reports submitted to NYC 311 by residents or the public. A report describes a reported issue, not a confirmed violation.

5.6 reports per 100 apartments, versus 28.7 for other comparable apartment buildings in New York.

CategoryReportsLatest
3
Apr 2025
2
Nov 2024
1
Mar 2024

HPD housing-code violationsPast 3 years

HPD housing-code violations
Housing-code violations issued by NYC’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development after an inspection. Routine administrative filings and notices are excluded.

No HPD violations recorded in this period.

2 additional older citations remain open.

Construction nearby

Construction nearby
Construction projects on or near this building with active work permits.
ProjectDistanceLatest permit
100 ftMay 2026
200 ftJul 2026
200 ftJun 2026

Rent history

Typical rents

Typical rents
Final asking rents from listings that ended in the past year.
1 bed
$4,495median / mo
$4,195–$4,995608 sq ft median

Concessions

Historical concessions
Free-rent offers on listings that ended in the past year, including listings with no offer.
AllStudio1 bed

4% of listings offered free rent, most commonly one month.

No free rent recorded: 96%1 month: 4%
4%of listings offered free rent
No free rent recorded
96%(27 of 28)
1 month
4%(1 of 28)

Similar buildings

Summit NYC
Midtown East
3.8 ★ (130)Google Maps
From $5,300 studio · 7 listings

A newer nearby rental with a larger amenity program; compare apartment size, utility treatment and the value of newer shared spaces.

The Buchanan
Midtown East
4.5 ★ (86)Google Maps
From $5,295 1 bed · 2 listings

Another East Side full-service rental with a different location and layout mix; compare total monthly charges, natural light and commute.