ApartmentBuildings.NYC

Areas

ManhattanBrowse buildingsBrooklynBrowse buildingsQueensBrowse buildingsBronxBrowse buildingsStaten IslandBrowse buildingsJersey CityBrowse buildingsHobokenBrowse buildings
Building exterior 2 photos

The Cole by Stonehenge

354 East 91st Street, NY 101284.0 ★ (70 reviews)
Rental building
Website

Summary

The Cole is a 163-apartment Upper East Side rental with full-time door staff, a penthouse lounge and fitness floor, a private courtyard and on-site laundry. Residents consistently praise the staff, maintenance and spacious renovated homes; recurring mouse concerns and smoke traveling between some apartments are the clearest drawbacks.

163 unitsOpened 2002Managed by Stonehenge NYC

Reviews

The Cole's strongest resident feedback centers on the people running the building and the amount of space for the price. Most accounts are highly positive, with a smaller set raising apartment-specific pest and smoke concerns.

Google
4.0
70 reviews
Yelp
1.0
1 review

What residents praise

Staff and maintenance stand out

Residents repeatedly describe the door, leasing and maintenance teams as friendly, responsive and quick to handle repairs or move-in questions.

Renovated homes can feel unusually spacious

Longer-term residents praise roomy layouts, strong appliances, upper-floor views and select balconies or in-home laundry.

The location works well for daily life

Residents value the subway, neighborhood shopping and a quieter Upper East Side setting within easy reach of Central Park.

What residents complain about

Check the exact apartment for mice

A detailed resident account describes repeated mice in the apartment despite extermination visits, and a separate recent housing complaint also involved pests.

Smoke can travel between apartments

A resident reports secondhand smoke entering through building pipes and says management struggled to stop it.

Amenities

A 2002 Yorkville rental with a 24-hour doorman and concierge, laundry rooms on each floor plus in-home washer/dryers in select apartments, and dishwashers throughout. The penthouse level holds a fitness center, lounge and billiards room; a landscaped courtyard, attached iPark garage and rentable storage cages complete the building.

In the apartment
In-unit laundry
Some apartments
Central air
Dishwasher
In the building
24-hour doorman
Elevator
Fitness center*
Pool
Not available
Shared outdoor space
On-site parking*
Package service
Resident storage*
Shared laundry

* Fees apply to marked amenities. See Costs in the Availability tab.

Also here: Bike storage · Residents' lounge · Billiards room · Live-in superintendent · Pet friendly (cats and dogs) · Smoke-free building

Location

The Cole by Stonehenge is located at 354 East 91st Street, New York, NY 10128. The Cole is on East 91st Street near the Second Avenue subway, neighborhood groceries and restaurants. Central Park and the 4, 5 and 6 at 86th Street are farther west, giving the building convenient east-side access without being directly on a major retail avenue.

TransitSupermarketsParks
  • 6 min
    86 StQ
  • 6 min
    96 StQ
  • 11 min
    86 St456
  • 11 min
    96 St6

Building records

Housing complaints are relatively uncommon compared with similar buildings, with elevators and heating the joint largest categories. Lift and heating reliability are the main service topics to ask about.

Reported housing complaintsPast 3 years

Reported housing complaints
Housing-related reports submitted to NYC 311 by residents or the public. A report describes a reported issue, not a confirmed violation.

9.2 reports per 100 apartments, versus 28.7 for other comparable apartment buildings in New York.

CategoryReportsLatest
3
Jul 2026
3
Jan 2026
2
Aug 2025

HPD housing-code violationsPast 3 years

HPD housing-code violations
Housing-code violations issued by NYC’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development after an inspection. Routine administrative filings and notices are excluded.
ConditionCitationsStatus
2
Closed
2
Closed
2
Closed

Rent history

Studios ask about 7% less than the Upper East Side median and are around 12% smaller. One-bedrooms ask about 1% more than the Upper East Side median and are around 7% smaller.

Typical rents

Typical rents
Final asking rents from listings that ended in the past year, compared with the same apartment size across buildings in Upper East Side.
Studio
$3,750median / mo
−7% vs area
$3,595–$3,995422 sq ft · 12% smaller than area
1 bed
$5,097median / mo
+1% vs area
$4,450–$6,040645 sq ft · 7% smaller than area
2 beds
$6,022median / mo
−10% vs area
$4,995–$7,700735 sq ft · 18% smaller than area

Concessions

Historical concessions
Free-rent offers on listings that ended in the past year, including listings with no offer.
AllStudio1 bed2 beds3 beds

About one in three listings offered free rent, most commonly one month. If the apartment you like doesn’t include an offer, it’s worth asking whether leasing can extend one.

No free rent recorded: 67%1 month: 27%1.5 months: 7%
33%of listings offered free rent
No free rent recorded
67%(50 of 75)
1 month
27%(20 of 75)
1.5 months
7%(5 of 75)

Similar buildings

303 East 83rd
Upper East Side
4.6 ★ (167)Google Maps
From $5,752 1 bed · 5 listings

A nearby full-service Upper East Side rental with a larger apartment count; compare layouts, amenity access, fees and current rent.

Normandie Court
Upper East Side
3.7 ★ (200)Google Maps
From $3,860 studio · 7 listings

A much larger Yorkville rental with broader shared spaces; compare management feedback, apartment size and total monthly cost.