West 54th is a 222-apartment Midtown West rental with spacious layouts, strong closet storage, a garden patio and 24-hour concierge. Residents consistently praise the on-site staff and maintenance, while renewal increases, elevator and laundry reliability, pests and uneven management decisions are the main drawbacks.
Residents repeatedly distinguish the friendly, responsive doormen, super and maintenance team from the broader ownership and renewal experience. Apartment size and storage are strengths, while aging shared systems and pest complaints account for most of the negative feedback.
Doormen, maintenance staff and the super receive sustained praise for kindness, fast repairs and making the building feel like home.
Residents value large closets, practical layouts and good light compared with many newer Midtown rentals.
Hell's Kitchen restaurants, transit and the river are close, while the block feels quieter than Times Square.
Residents report increases near 10% and describe limited flexibility despite positive experiences in the building.
Broken machines, long elevator repairs and periods with only one working car recur across resident accounts.
Roach or silverfish complaints, water damage and slow escalation appear in a smaller but meaningful group of reviews.
West 54th has central air, a 24-hour attended lobby and a shared laundry room. Residents have a fitness center, landscaped courtyard and sundeck with grills, with an on-site garage and private storage.
* Fees apply to marked amenities. See Costs in the Availability tab.
Also here: Bike storage · On-site grocery · Resident lounge
West 54th is located at 505 West 54th Street, New York, NY 10019. West 54th is at Tenth Avenue near DeWitt Clinton Park and the Hudson River, with Hell's Kitchen dining and Columbus Circle within walking distance. The A/C/B/D/1 trains are farther east, so station access is less immediate than at central Midtown buildings.
playground
Housing complaints are relatively uncommon compared with similar buildings, with noise accounting for most reports. Heat and hot-water issues also appear, making service reliability a useful topic to ask about.
7.2 reports per 100 apartments, versus 28.7 for other comparable apartment buildings in New York.
| Category | Reports | Latest | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
10 | May 2026 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
2 | Oct 2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 | Jan 2026 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 | Mar 2026 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 | Jun 2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
1 | Jun 2025 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
No housing-condition violations recorded in this period.
3 additional older citations remain open.
| Project | Work type | Distance | Latest permit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion | 750 ft | Sep 2026 | |
Conversion to residential use. Permitted work: general construction. | |||
Studios ask about 8% less than the Hell S Kitchen median, with similar apartment sizes. One-bedrooms ask about 15% less than the Hell S Kitchen median and are around 1% smaller.
| Apartment | Range | Median rent | Median size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $3,556–$4,138 | $3,711 −8% vs area | 522 sf Same as area |
| 1 bed | $3,896–$5,291 | $4,324 −15% vs area | 660 sf −1% vs area |
| 2 beds | $6,045–$8,189 | $6,702 −10% vs area | 962 sf −10% vs area |
No free-rent offers appeared in the past year’s listings.

A nearby established rental with a different amenity and apartment mix; compare layout, river access, fees and current rent.

A more central Midtown rental closer to major subway lines; compare station access, neighborhood noise, apartment size and total cost.
| Apartment | Beds | Rent | Size (sq ft) | Available | Days listed | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
#727#727 | Studio | $4,106 | 493 | Nov 4, 26 | 28 | StreetEasy |
#601#601 | 1 bed | $4,758 | 631 | Sep 22, 26 | 91 | StreetEasy |
#815#815 | 1 bed | $5,271 | 659 | Sep 22, 26 | 35 | StreetEasy |
#103#103 | 2 beds | $7,068 | 1,020 | Nov 19, 26 | 18 | StreetEasy |
How fast they go: Recent listings spent a median of 30 days on the market, versus 17 days at comparable apartment buildings nearby. 16% left within a week.
| Apartment | Beds | Last asking rent | Size (sq ft) | Last on market | Est. lease end | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
#1217#1217 | Studio | $3,259 | 418 | ~1 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#715#715 | Studio | $3,700 | 550 | ~1 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#204#204 | 1 bed | $4,751 | 690 | ~1 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#403#403 | 1 bed | $4,211 | 637 | ~1 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#602#602 | 1 bed | $4,499 | 730 | ~2 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#913#913 | 2 beds | $5,539 | 933 | ~2 yr ago | Oct 2026 | StreetEasy |
#927#927 | Studio | $3,556 | 493 | ~1 yr ago | Nov 2026 | StreetEasy |
#423#423 | 1 bed | $4,019 | 630 | ~1 yr ago | Nov 2026 | StreetEasy |
#PH11#PH11 | 1 bed | $3,961 | 651 | ~1 yr ago | Nov 2026 | StreetEasy |
#519#519 | 2 beds | $6,846 | 1,091 | ~1 yr ago | Nov 2026 | StreetEasy |
#710#710 | Studio | $3,632 | 522 | ~1 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#1225#1225 | 1 bed | $4,007 | 583 | ~1 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#304#304 | 1 bed | $4,142 | 690 | ~1 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#502#502 | 1 bed | $4,574 | 730 | ~1 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#608#608 | 1 bed | $4,148 | 631 | ~1 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#827#827 | Studio | $3,495 | 493 | ~2 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
#814#814 | 1 bed | $4,559 | 658 | ~3 yr ago | Dec 2026 | StreetEasy |
Past availability and off-market dates suggest these apartments may be nearing the end of their current lease. If a resident doesn’t renew, the apartment could become available. Ask the leasing team early about any unit that interests you.
New listings in past 12 months
Budget about $395/month on top of rent for one person, including utilities, the $50/month internet package and the required $58/person monthly amenity fee.
| Cost | Monthly amount |
|---|---|
Utilities Utilities Electricity~$110 Paid separately. Estimated $110/month. Water~$35 Estimate based on 12 months of utility billing; actual usage varies. Sewer~$55 Estimate based on 12 months of utility billing; actual usage varies. Gas / central boiler~$83 Estimate based on 12 months of utility billing; actual usage varies. Utility administration$5 $5 monthly billing fee. Source: West 54th fees · Con Edison bill illustration | ~$288 |
Internet Internet Required $50/month internet package. Source: West 54th fees | $50 |
Amenities Amenities Required $58/month per person for amenities. Tax is included. Source: West 54th fees | $58 |
Estimated monthly total incl. required amenities for 1 person
~$395Also available: Pets ($100/month) · Storage ($30–$155/month)
| Cost | One-time amount |
|---|---|
| Application Application $17 application fee. Source: West 54th fees | $17 |
| Holding deposit Holding deposit Refundable $500 deposit to reserve the apartment, credited toward the security deposit. Source: West 54th fees | $500 |
| Security deposit Security deposit Refundable deposit of $3,050; the amount varies by apartment and approval. Source: West 54th fees | $3,050 |
| Utility setup Utility setup One-time utility billing setup fee. Source: West 54th fees | $10 |
